Big Box Store Yarn vs. Local Yarn Store Yarn: What’s the Difference?

Big Box Store Yarn vs. Local Yarn Store Yarn: What’s the Difference?

Big Box Store Yarn vs. Local Yarn Store Yarn: What’s the Difference?

Hello fellow yarn lovers!

Ever wandered the aisles of a big box store, eyes gleaming at the rows of yarn in every color under the sun?  Or maybe you’ve strolled into a cozy local yarn store (LYS), where the smell of wool and the soft hum of chatter makes you feel right at home. Both places have their charm, but have you ever wondered what really sets their yarn apart? Let’s talk about it.

The Big Box Store Yarn

Big box stores are all about convenience. Need yarn at 8:00 PM on a Tuesday?  Chances are they will still be open.  The yarn here is often mass-produced, which means it’s super affordable. You’ll find loads of acrylics, cotton blends, and some wool, perfect for those big projects like blankets where you need a lot of yarn without breaking the bank.

But here’s the thing: while the price is right, the quality can sometimes be hit or miss. Since it’s mass-produced, the fibers might not be as soft or durable as you’d like, and the colors might be a bit more limited in depth and variety. Still, for basic projects, kids' crafts, or if you’re just starting out, big box store yarn is a solid choice.  Take Big Twist Posh, for example.  It is my absolute favorite yarn for amigurumi – bar none – and is only available at Joann’s.  Every time I pick it up, I can’t help perusing the other available yarns (which seem to be dwindling these days).

The Local Yarn Store Yarn

Now, the LYS – the LYS is where yarn dreams come true.  Walking into one is like entering a world of texture, color, and inspiration. The yarn here is often hand-dyed, artisanal, and carefully curated. You’ll find fibers you never even knew existed—like baby alpaca, yak, or luxurious silk blends. The colors are richer, the texture softer, and the overall experience is positively decadent.

Yes, the price tag can be higher, but you’re paying for quality and uniqueness, and often buying yarn that’s been crafted with love and care.   Also, LYS owners and staff are usually passionate knitters and crocheters themselves, always ready with advice, pattern suggestions, or just a friendly chat.  

So, Which is Better?

Honestly, it depends on your project and your priorities. For everyday projects or when you need a lot of yarn quickly, big box store yarn is fantastic. But when you’re working on something special, or you just want to treat yourself, nothing beats the experience and quality of yarn from a local yarn store.

The Sustainable Choice: Resale LYS Yarn Online

Now, let’s talk about something close to our hearts—sustainability!  If you’re passionate about being eco-friendly, buying resale yarn is a wonderful option. Many LYS owners and crafters sell gently used or leftover yarn from their stash, giving those fibers a second life. Instead of ending up in a landfill, that beautiful skein you snagged online gets a new chance to become something amazing.

By choosing resale yarn, you’re not only scoring some unique, high-quality fibers at a fraction of the price, but you’re also helping to reduce waste. Plus, you’re minimizing the environmental impact associated with producing new yarn. It’s a win-win for you and our planet.  Shopping resale also supports a circular economy within the crafting community, where materials are reused and recycled rather than discarded. It’s like being part of a big, eco-friendly yarn swap, where everyone wins, especially our children and grandchildren.

So next time you’re on the hunt for yarn, consider checking out Treasured Yarns online. You’ll feel good about your purchase and maybe even find some hidden gems that’ll make your project truly one-of-a-kind.

Back to blog